Skip to main content
Open
Glossary
Close
Glossary
2024 Report Title Picture

2024 Report: State of EU progress to climate neutrality

SHARE
Download Executive Summary Download Full Report
Eike Karola Velten • Clara Calipel • Matthias Duwe • Nick Evans • Charlotte Felthöfer • Jonathan Gardiner • Markus Hagemann • Finn Hossfeld • Ciarán Humphreys • Lukas Kahlen • Simon Lalieu • Martyna Leśniak • Julien Pestiaux • Paula Schöberlein • Aleksander Śniegocki • Aneta Stefańczyk • John Tarpey

The second annual assessment of progress towards climate neutrality confirms that the EU is moving in the right direction, but that the pace is still too slow

Electricity, industry, just transition and cleantech are key building blocks showing signs of improvement in specific indicators compared to last year’s analysis.

Explore progress across all 13 building blocks

 

Encouraging signs of progress bubbling under the surface

The EU has kept up its progress towards climate neutrality in many building blocks for a climate neutral society. Even though all 13 building blocks remain in the same classification as in 2023, a closer look reveals important and promising progress in individual indicators and in terms of policy. 

Read more about past progress

Implementation of existing policies is key - but that is not all!

This second annual ECNO progress check identifies key areas of action for EU-policy-makers. It comes at a political juncture for EU policy, with a newly elected EU Parliament and soon a new EU Commission. 

Read more about key policy actions

Findings 2024

Promising signs of progress in data and policies

Even though all 13 building blocks remain in the same progress category as in the 2023 assessment, a closer look reveals important and promising progress in individual indicators and in new and revised policies. 

Explore all building blocks in detail Our approach

Movement in the right direction in most building blocks

Concerns over pace of change remain, but cleantech and electricity on the verge of progressing at the right pace

EU climate governance remains on track, as shown by high-level management frameworks and institutions being put in place at national and EU levels. On the brink of being assessed as on track are clean technologies and electricity. The needed changes here are being set in motion, but for the moment still somewhat too slow

In addition, just transition was progressing at a too slow pace, with small yet important improvements in individual areas particularly on reducing poverty in coal and heavy industry regions and on creating job opportunities. Progress was still far too slow in the sectors agrifood, buildings, industry, mobility, as well as lifestyles. Progress was also still far too slow for the EU’s external action. Moreover, the EU remains poorly equipped with regards to adaptation to climate change. 

Industry
CDR

U-turn needed on finance and carbon dioxide removals

Perhaps most alarmingly, in comparison to the 2023 assessment, there was only little advancement and even some deteriorations in finance, as public funds for fossil fuels increased while the share of environmental tax revenues declined. Redirecting financial flows towards the transition is essential to put the EU on track to achieve climate neutrality by 2050. This includes both public and private investment flows.  In carbon dioxide removal, natural sinks and related forest growth kept decreasing, although at a lesser speed compared to last year’s assessment. Thus, these two building blocks keep moving in the wrong direction.

Change is happening under the emissions curve 

Individual indicators show progress in important areas

In the case of ten individual indicators, the changes were so significant that they resulted in an improved classification. At the same time, three indicators slowed down in their progress leading to a lower classification.

Progress under the emissions curve
10 indicators with improved classifications
  • Electricity: Share of variable renewable electricty 
  • Agrifood: GHG emissions
  • Industry: GHG emissions
  • Industry: Share of clean energy carriers and feedstock use
  • Industry: Energy intensity of output 
  • Just transition: Regional poverty rate 
  • Just transition: Employment in renewable energy supply chains
  • Just transition: Share of support for households
  • Cleantech: Public funds for environmental and energy R&D
  • External action: ODA allocated to climate action
3 indicators with worsened classifications
  • Electricity: GHG emissions of electricity generation
  • Just transition: Average of four relevant sub-indicators in the material deprivation rate
  • Just transition: Share of support for energy efficiency purposes

A closer look at progress in enablers towards a climate neutral future

This year’s report includes in-depth analyses of four enablers to better understand the changes in Member States that are driving the EU trends. 

  • Implementing zero emission transport in mobility
  • Storing more carbon in trees in carbon dioxide removals
  • Channelling public funds away from fossil fuels in finance
  • Creating job opportunities in just transition

Swipe to look at the findings of the deep dives!

Explore the deep dives

Implementing zero emission transport

Enabler Deep Dive 1

The adoption of Zero and Low Emission Vehicles (ZEVs) has significantly increased across all Member States, with most using financial incentives or bonus-malus systems, to promote their purchasing. However, the predominance of ZEVs in the high-priced vehicle segment means their uptake remains especially notable in Member States with greater purchasing power. More than 50% of charging points are in the Netherlands, Germany, and France. The dense Dutch network results from a clear national agenda and ambitious subnational policies.

Read more about progress on this enabler

Storing more carbon in trees

Enabler Deep Dive 2

Despite recent signs of decreasing net LULUCF removals, forest area and carbon stock in forest land has grown between 2016 and 2021, mostly in France, where the government also introduced its so-called low-carbon label to certify carbon removal projects. Additionally, Italy and Bulgaria are driving positive change in forest area, and Poland and Germany show promising developments in terms of growing carbon stock in forest land. Overall, there still is a lack of a coordinated forest policy framework, harmonising forest regulations across regions and fostering carbon sequestration and ecosystem restoration.

Read more about progress on this enabler

Channelling public funds away from fossil fuels

Enabler Deep Dive 3

Amid the energy crisis of 2022, fossil fuel subsidies have risen in nearly all Member States except Finland, Romania, Luxembourg, and Bulgaria. While most plan to phase out these subsidies, the focus is often limited to the power sector and, to a lesser extent, the buildings sector, with other sectors mostly omitted from such plans. Germany and France have committed to exit fossil fuel subsidies but have not set a specific end-date for all. Denmark stands out as the only Member State having set out a comprehensive national plan to concretely phase out fossil fuel subsidies related to electricity generation, coal-fired power plants, and support in fossil heating systems.

Read more about progress on this enabler

Creating job opportunities

Enabler Deep Dive 4

The employment rate in the regions most affected by the transition is progressing at a pace that is similar to the pace for the whole EU. The rates in transitioning regions are on average markedly higher in the countries that are characterised by high overall employment. Thereby, country-level specific factors and policies may so far be more effective than JTF region-specific support. Job creation in renewable energy has increased most in Portugal, followed by Germany and Spain, with photovoltaics being the most employing technology. National programmes such as the ‘Green Skills and Job Programme’ in Portugal or a training academy in a former coal region in Romania are supporting this development.

Read more about progress on this enabler

The EU is on its journey to become climate neutral by 2050. This multi-generational project holds many societal, economic, and environmental opportunities. At the same time, it is of unprecedented scale and implies considerable changes to the current systems. Regular progress checking is the key to understanding where the EU stands on this journey. 

renewable energy wind

Actions for the EU policy cycle 2024-2029

The 2024 ECNO assessment of the EU’s progress towards climate neutrality reveals 10 key areas where targeted policy actions are required in the legislative cycle 2024-2029 to get on track to net zero and a more competitive and just EU.

 

1: Advance effective implementation of existing policies

The broad set of policies adopted in the past four years has moved the EU firmly into the implementation phase of the transition to net zero emissions. National implementation is mentioned as a key action area in each building block, indicating its enormous potential in the next policy cycle. National policies need to be enhanced in several areas, including, e.g., support for and better integration of renewables, infrastructure development, and moving from a linear to a circular economy. National decision-making is best supported by high-quality national long-term strategies (LTS), national energy and climate plans (NECPs), progress reports (NECPRs), and meaningful public participation – all of which can be improved in most countries. EU-level support to Member States, along with further specification of the legal requirements and stricter follow-up to ensure adherence, would further facilitate national implementation.

2: Get the finance right for the transition

Without a turn-around on finance and realising the necessary investments, the transition could fail. A strong policy push is needed to redirect financial flows towards transition financing, including progressively phasing out fossil fuel subsidies, and to close the investment gap. Progress could be made by developing a new EU-level long-term transition financing plan. Such a plan should include EU public funding tools and clarify the role of, and rules for, Member States’ funding. It should also set out whether existing regulations (such as the EU ETS) are sufficient to crowd in private finance or whether they need to be strengthened. Furthermore, it should provide information on EU funds allocation for the next EU long-term budget, the Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF), for 2028 to 2034. The EU can also support Member States in developing action plans for phasing out fossil fuel subsidies (which is already a long-standing commitment) and shifting resources to support sustainable investments, which address the root causes of energy poverty and energy security risks.

3: Ensure a socially just and people-centred transition

EU citizens show strong support for climate action but also express concerns over an uncertain future. To maintain citizens’ resolve, further progress is needed to ensure that they feel engaged in the process and that no one is left behind. A citizen-centric approach to decisions over the coming years could strengthen this dimension. Related actions would include developing job opportunities and creating adequate training programmes in relevant industries, as well as ensuring people have access to sustainable lifestyle options. Material deprivation and poverty can be better kept in check by moving from temporary protection instruments to structural measures that help manage distributional effects. Moreover, citizens should be given early and frequent opportunities to contribute to policy decisions. A critical starting point is improving national implementation of EU requirements, including public participation in climate policy planning and the establishment of permanent multi-level dialogues. All channels for engagement should be designed for impact with adequate political attention and follow-up.

4: Accelerate the industrial transition as part of an EU competitiveness deal

Making EU industry fit for the age of net zero promotes innovation and increases international competitiveness and resilience over the long term. Providing additional dedicated EU-level funding, especially for electrification, grid infrastructure, and energy efficiency, and leveraging existing spending via improved green public procurement frameworks may accelerate the progress of the industrial transition in the EU. This support would help companies overcome financial obstacles to invest in and adopt new and improved technologies. Further progress would need comprehensive and consistent national energy and climate plans (NECPs) that consider the three enablers – circularity, energy efficiency, and zero carbon energy carriers, including electrification and the necessary infrastructure.

5: Encourage efficiency, modal shifts and electrification in buildings and mobility

Mobility and buildings need dedicated additional policy action to increase progress. In buildings, the achievement of wide-spread deep renovation could be helped through compliance support and an enforcement system. For performance standards to be effective, accessible, and affordable, they should be integrated with supportive policy instruments, tailored to the needs of the target groups. An example are subsidies to address the financial barriers faced by low-income and vulnerable households, as well as rental units. In mobility, the EU can accelerate progress by targeting high-mileage corporate fleets, expanding the availability of and access to cross-border public transport and supporting Member States in their national zero-emission vehicle incentive schemes and in the corresponding infrastructure development. Progress towards managing motorised freight transport could be made by encouraging local, circular industry.

6: Ensure a predictable and just transition in agriculture

Across Europe, farmers expressed their concerns over the economic viability of their livelihoods in early 2024. At the same time, changes in current agricultural practices are essential to reaching climate neutrality. While farmers have started reorganising their businesses, a clear vision and reliable framework for the transition would further support their efforts. The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) has the potential to shift public funds to incentivise low-emission, socially just, and resilient agriculture and to provide a predictable economic outlook for farmers. Standardised, stringent criteria for sustainable food procurement and labelling would support healthier, plant-based diets. Lastly, action can be taken to reduce food waste through stricter guidelines on responsible food business and marketing practices, acting on date marking, and mandating emission reductions from agrifood distributors and processors, while also engaging nonfarming actors in the transition.

7: Invest in (natural) carbon dioxide removals urgently

Without Carbon Dioxide Removals (CDR), the EU cannot achieve climate neutrality – and current trends are worrying. There is an urgent need to further expand sustainable forest practices and promote restoration, reforestation, and sustainable management. Progress could be made by addressing the risks of fast-growing plantation forests, encouraging a shift away from monoculture towards near-natural forests with a greater mix in tree species, and promoting biodiversity and forests resilience. Any certified removals being used to account for residual emissions will have to be of high integrity to ensure permanence. To enable the deployment of sustainable technical CDR post-2030, progress should be made on research, development, and demonstration with a greater focus to be placed on full lifecycle impacts.

8: Enhance global climate action through international climate finance and diplomacy

Global action is an essential part of successful climate policy and is also in the EU’s interest. The EU could advance its own contribution through effectively implementing existing partnerships, promoting sustainable trade practices, and supporting stringent, transparent, equitable, and effective environmental standards. Looking ahead, the EU’s foreign and trade policy could centre on the global transformation. A key dimension is also the provision of international climate finance that corresponds to the EU’s fair share. To reinforce its commitment to financing clean projects abroad, progress could be made by transforming the European Investment Bank into a true ‘climate bank’ – phasing out fossil-fuel financing and supporting renewable energy, energy efficiency, and climate resilience.

Institutional policy actions

9: Improve data for smarter policy-making

Transition tracking such as done in this assessment is limited by the availability of data. 36 out of the 124 indicators showed data availability issues, hindering the assessment of progress on key objectives and enablers of the transition. To enhance information for policy-makers, action is needed to close gaps in data needed to monitor the transition. Options include implementing new or better reporting obligations and adjusting data collection routines to improve the efficiency of processes and spending. Streamlining existing reporting processes could help simplify processes, reduce the administrative effort, and free up capacity.

10: Establish an official EU-wide transition monitoring

While ECNO’s assessment provides detailed input for policy-makers, it cannot replace regular and sufficiently comprehensive EU-wide transition monitoring carried out by the EU institutions directly. The current system cannot deliver the necessary information. By integrating existing planning, monitoring, and reporting activities, a revised EU transition monitoring framework could lead to greater comparability, facilitate evaluations, and increase transparency. It could reduce overall effort and administrative burden for Member States and EU institutions alike. The upcoming review and potential revisions of the EU Climate Law and the Governance Regulation may offer an opening for this.

Download Executive Summary
Share this page